Syracuse transfer Rickie Collins has a tough act to follow in Kennesaw. We were always going to judge the Owls’ new starting quarterback against Amari Odom’s end result: First-team All CUSA, a 4th-and-14 conversion against Jacksonville State, and smoking cigars as a champion on the Gamecocks’ home turf.

We don’t talk as much about the three back-breaking interceptions Odom threw the first time the two teams played. Or what happened in the bowl game. Or really anything else from last season outside the highlight reel.

Endless “trade” references only add fuel to the fire comparing the two quarterbacks. One quarter into the season, can we put together a progress report for Collins?

We’ll never get a fair view across seasons, but we can try our best by looking at the numbers through each player’s first three games with the Owls. Odom took the reins one drive into the Indiana game, played a majority of snaps against Merrimack, and got a wire-to-wire start vs. a G6 opponent in our own weight class (Arkansas State, coincidently). That roughly lines up with Collins’ half against West Georgia, complete game against Georgia State, and a buy game against Tennessee.

The tale of the tape through three weeks of action:

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Hoot State to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Adam Calhoun1 month ago

I feel like Collins is so worried about making mistakes that it limits the owls passing potential. I thought he had some good opportunities against Tennessee and it looked like he tucked the ball and ran a bit too early when we pushed into the red zone. I can understand that in the first half but once we are down 30+ with a defense missing Hopson it felt like we needed to take a few more chances. I feel like the Arkansas State game is way more important now and will hopefully give us an idea if we have the ability to score 20+ points consistently

Avatar

AJ HowardAuthor1 month ago

You’re not wrong on the quick trigger to take off. Chicken vs. egg situation with the levels of pressure. Think he is anticipating (usually right) his tackles getting nuked on every obvious passing down. They’ve gotten into some of the deep choice stuff but keep getting sit reads against soft coverage so we haven’t seen as much of the deep ball. Definitely need to see the play sheet expand on Saturday though.

Congrats on being the first ever comment on this site, by the way. Thanks for reading.